I think Andy is just fresher in his mind. I’m still objectively the best boyfriend he’s had and at my peak I was the hottest.
And he is not a pedophile. You could make a somewhat weak argument about Ephebophilia, but his attraction lies in people who look like they’re teens, not actual teens below 18. His hyper fixations on the subject makes him look very guilty because he doubts himself and the fact that he’s a good person with no bad intentions.